Constructive essay comments
Red ink looks like blood and screams at the student, "How dare you make this mistake! More common was a dearth of quotes, and more common still, a dearth of citations.
Negative essay comments
Are you saying in ten words what could be said in three? Your conclusion here is a bookend, bringing up the same or at least a similar point as the one you began with concerning the different kinds of attraction that exist. Another common and related approach was to give a paragraph by paragraph regurgitation of the text. That is, don't just summarize all the mistakes you've marked or point out all the deficiencies in the paper so that the student won't object to the grade you assign. Looking at them in essence and in isolation, do any of them contradict each other? Again, the paper shows a good grasp of some of the basic points made in the literature, weaving together a number of overlapping ideas. More than just a bookend, however, you want your conclusion to be in the service of your argument.
You can usually claim to have found something "interesting" or perhaps "provocative" that the student has said. Not only did you fulfill the assignment, you also wrote a long-ish intro and answered questions that went beyond the prompt. My comments below, however, are indicative of the tone and approach I take toward papers I consider to be significantly inadequate.
To avoid this error, have a detailed read through your essay before you submit it and look in particular detail at the statements you make. As noted throughout, the biggest weakness of the paper is the occasional lack of clarity.
Again, the paper shows a good grasp of some of the basic points made in the literature, weaving together a number of overlapping ideas.
Constructive feedback essay sample
Using sexist language is simply unprofessional and stylistically immature. Every piece of writing has some strengths, so look for them and be prepared to point them out. Read the whole thing. I gave them, pointing out where her plot seemed to lag and the characters felt flat. Be the best writer in the office. Rogers , p. Make sure that your reasons really do support or lead to the conclusion you come to. Share your ideas and tips. More Sample Comments Example 1: Good analysis of similarities between the two novels. Read deeply. To avoid this error, have a detailed read through your essay before you submit it and look in particular detail at the statements you make. This is crucial if feedback is to be understood by students and to maintain their self esteem. Enough time needs to be given for students to understand the feedback and compose any questions.
based on 99 review